Ideal Eyebrow Pencils of 2024 for That All-natural Appearance

It’s practically unintelligible that till regarding ten years earlier, a lot of us tackled our lives without filling out our arcs. Luckily, brow items have actually come to be essentials in modern-day make-up application. Whether you grab it everyday or simply when you’re going with a thicker appearance, an excellent eyebrow pencil has an area in every glam package.

Gels, powders, and pomades have their usages, yet if we might just pick one eyebrow item, we would certainly choose this easy unrecognized hero. “For the most sensible impact … turn it at a 45-degree angle to your skin and attract fast, slim strokes to mimic hair,” recommends star make-up musician Bryan Cantor. After that brush, mix, and fluff with a spoolie.

The eyebrow filler market is rather filled now. To aid you look with your choices, we attempted almost 40 book The Laboratory, after that tightened it to those with the most effective suggestions, pigments, and remaining power.

These are the most effective eyebrow pencils evaluated by Byrdie.

Our Leading Picks.

Ideal Total:.

Runner-Up, Ideal Total:.

Ideal Budget plan:.

Ideal Splurge:.

Ideal Water resistant:.

Best for Sporadic Eyebrows:.

Ideal Pharmacy:.

Ideal Vegan:.

In This Short article.

Ideal Total.

Charlotte Tilbury Refillable Brow Pencil.

Sephora

$ 26.

Our Scores.

Feeling.

5/5.
Reduce of Usage.

5/5.
Pigment.

5/5.
Shield Variety.

4.5/ 5.
Use.

4/5.

What We Like.

Very pigmented
Accuracy idea
Easy to steer

What We Do not Like.

Absolutely Nothing

After attempting loads of items firsthand, Charlotte Tilbury’s Eyebrow Cheat was our fave. Our tester made use of the all-natural black color and enjoyed exactly how the extremely pigmented shade appeared plainly without being as well raw or frustrating. Not just that, yet she had the ability to make use of realistic-looking hairs in a solitary stroke– no layering required.

The formula has a matte coating, so it looks all-natural and assimilate with your genuine hairs. Flaunting a slim, tilted idea, this pencil is best for accuracy application. You can utilize it to complete sporadic eyebrows or produce an organized form. Our tester stated the velvety structure takes place efficiently without dragging, and the strong factor withstands splitting and smooshing.

The dual-ended layout has actually a connected spoolie to aid with mixing, fluffing, and shaping. It’s likewise refillable– sort of like a mechanical pencil– so you can lower your waste. Offered in 8 true-to-tone tones that assure 16 hours of water-proof wear, we truly have no problems regarding this item.

Tones: 8| Waterproof: Yes | Cruelty-Free: Yes

Byrdie/ Tamara Staples
Byrdie/ Tamara Staples
Byrdie/ Tamara Staples

What Our Testers Claim

” The pigment is highly tinted and takes place totally without being frustrating, and you just need to use each stroke as soon as without requiring to layer it.”— Madison Yauger, Item Tester

Runner-Up, Ideal Total.

Anastasia Beverly Hills Eyebrow Definer.

Amazon

$ 26.

Our Scores.

Feeling.

5/5.
Reduce of Usage.

5/5.
Pigment.

5/5.
Shield Variety.

4/5.
Use.

3.5/ 5.

What We Like.

Fills out superb strokes
Very pigmented
Does not spot

What We Do not Like.

Black color might be softer

We attempted 2 pencils from Anastasia Beverly Hills, and while we such as the Eyebrow Wiz, we love the Eyebrow Definer. Calling it the “gold criterion of eyebrow pens,” our tester stated the uniformity is velvety sufficient to produce soft lines without subduing your existing hairs.

The inclined triangular idea is functional and straightforward. You can make slim strokes, detail your arcs, or color them, after that turn it over and mix every little thing out with the integrated spoolie. While the Eyebrow Definer isn’t water-proof, our tester stated the durable pigment withstands smearing. Past that, we simply want it can be found in a soft black color.

Tones: 12| Waterproof: No | Cruelty-Free: Yes.

Byrdie/ Tamara Staples
Byrdie/ Tamara Staples
Byrdie/ Tamara Staples

Trick Attributes

” The gold criterion of eyebrow pens, you can see why Anastasia is still the leader: completely tilted, not as well slim, not as well fat or hefty.”— Mayra Mangal, Item Tester

Ideal Budget plan.

e.l.f. Eyebrow Pencil.

Ulta

$ 3.

Our Scores.

Feeling.

3/5.
Reduce of Usage.

4/5.
Pigment.

2/5.
Shield Variety.

3/5.
Use.

1/5.

What We Like.

Tough idea
Easy to use
Completely pigmented

What We Do not Like.

Restricted tones
Not transfer-resistant

Trying to find something more economical? This eyebrow pencil from e.l.f just sets you back a couple of dollars and holds its very own versus costlier choices. After filling out her thick eyebrows with the deep brownish color, our tester stated it’s smooth and velvety with a durable idea, making it simple to use.

Though we want it can be found in a couple of even more tones, this item uses the best quantity of pigment: plenty saturated yet not as well hefty. Because it’s not water-proof, our tester stated it abrades rather conveniently. However on the whole, we were amazed and would absolutely purchase it once more.

Tones: 5| Waterproof: No | Cruelty-Free: Yes.

Byrdie/ Tamara Staples
Byrdie/ Tamara Staples
Byrdie/ Tamara Staples
Byrdie/ Tamara Staples

What Our Testers Claim

” It’s the correct amount of pigment, not excessively hefty, yet filled sufficient to really complete my eyebrows.”— Kiara Timo, Item Tester

Ideal Splurge.

Gucci Pastel Définition Sourcils Powder Brow Pencil.

Sephora

$ 33.

Our Scores.

Feeling.

4/5.
Reduce of Usage.

4/5.
Pigment.

5/5.
Shield Variety.

2/5.
Use.

5/5.

What We Like.

Outstanding wear
Features integrated sharpener
Ultra-pigmented
Able to produce hairlike strokes

What We Do not Like.

Can be available in even more tones

If the high cost does not transform you away, you could take into consideration spending lavishly on Gucci’s Pastel Définition Sourcils. Upon attempting the color 03 Châtain (brown), our tester stated the velvety structure slides on efficiently, and the light-weight layout makes it simple to attract hair-like strokes. What’s even more, the pigment really did not spot whatsoever when she repetitively scrubed her eyebrows.

Though Pastel Définition Sourcils converts to “brow specifying pencil,” the thick idea is undoubtedly similar to a pastel. It features a sharpener, so you can make it a little pointier if required.

Tones: 6| Waterproof: No | Cruelty-Free: No.

Byrdie/ Tamara Staples
Byrdie/ Tamara Staples
Byrdie/ Tamara Staples

What Our Testers Claim

” In spite of massaging my eyebrows repetitively, there was definitely no smudging.”— Dawlat Chebly, Item Tester

Ideal Water resistant.

HUDA Appeal Eyebrow Pencil.

Sephora

$ 17.

Our Scores.

Feeling.

5/5.
Reduce of Usage.

5/5.
Pigment.

4/5.
Shield Variety.

4/5.
Use.

3/5.

What We Like.

Accuracy idea
Does not drag or miss
Spot- and transfer-proof

What We Do not Like.

Restricted color array

Huda’s #BombBrows was a hit in The Laboratory. Flaunting the “thinnest idea on the marketplace,” our tester enjoyed exactly how the accuracy factor down payments simply the correct amount of pigment and does not drag or miss, making it simple to produce natural-looking hairs. Not just that, yet the water-proof formula withstands smearing and moving for hours at a time.

The pencil itself is simple to hold, and there’s a spoolie on the various other end for mixing and fluffing. While there are 8 tones to select from, they’re mainly focused within a tool brownish array. Apart from that, the cost factor is ideal for a top notch item: obtainable yet not so affordable it makes you questionable.

Tones: 8| Waterproof: Yes | Cruelty-Free: Yes.

Byrdie/ Tamara Staples
Byrdie/ Tamara Staples
Byrdie/ Tamara Staples
Byrdie/ Tamara Staples
Byrdie/ Tamara Staples

What Our Testers Claim

” The pencil does not drag or miss; it’s an extremely slim factor, yet it provides you the pigment you require.”— Nikki Berryman, Item Tester

Best for Sporadic Eyebrows.

As Well Encountered Super Penalty Eyebrow Detailer Brow Pencil.

Sephora

$ 25.

Our Scores.

Feeling.

5/5.
Reduce of Usage.

5/5.
Pigment.

5/5.
Shield Variety.

4/5.
Use.

5/5.

What We Like.

Accuracy idea
Buttery structure
Natural-looking pigment

What We Do not Like.

Minor smearing

If you’re dealing with sporadic brows, Also Encountered is your best choice. Our tester stated the brand name’s Super Penalty Eyebrow Detailer has a buttery uniformity: not as well damp or completely dry and silky-smooth on the skin. The accuracy idea makes it simple to attract hair-like strokes, and it really did not damage or smoosh whatsoever while she filled out her eyebrows.

Offered in 8 tones varying from soft black to taupe, the pigment uses obvious, natural-looking shade. Something to note is that while the formula is water-proof, our tester stated it smeared a little when she ran her finger over her eyebrow.

Tones: 8| Waterproof: Yes | Cruelty-Free: Yes.

Byrdie/ Tamara Staples
Byrdie/ Tamara Staples
Byrdie/ Tamara Staples
Byrdie/ Tamara Staples
Byrdie/ Tamara Staples

Ideal Pharmacy.

NYX Expert Make-up Brow Pomade.

Amazon

$ 12.

$ 13.

Our Scores.

Feeling.

4/5.
Reduce of Usage.

4.5/ 5.
Pigment.

5/5.
Shield Variety.

4/5.
Use.

3.5/ 5.

What We Like.

Smooth and velvety
Triangular idea
One-of-a-kind fluffing brush

What We Do not Like.

Possibly as well pigmented

NYX is a pharmacy staple you can depend on for cost effective, extensively obtainable make-up. Situation in factor: this wallet-friendly brow pencil. (We really attempted 2 of the brand name’s pencils, yet this set made out a little much better in The Laboratory.) Our tester stated the smooth and velvety pomade formula functioned well for filling out her eyebrows.

The inclined triangular idea has an accuracy factor and a thicker side, so you have the choice to attract great lines or specify your arcs. As opposed to a spoolie, there’s a toothbrush-shaped brush on the various other end for mixing and fluffing. Our tester stated the pigment is rather extreme, so you’ll intend to utilize an extremely light hand when developing hair-like strokes.

Tones: 9| Waterproof: No | Cruelty-Free: Yes.

Byrdie/ Tamara Staples
Byrdie/ Tamara Staples
Byrdie/ Tamara Staples
Byrdie/ Tamara Staples

Ideal Vegan.

Kosas Specifying Brow Pencil.

Sephora

$ 24.

Our Scores.

Feeling.

5/5.
Reduce of Usage.

5/5.
Pigment.

4/5.
Shield Variety.

3/5.
Use.

3.5/ 5.

What We Like.

Triangular idea
Three-step system
Straightforward

What We Do not Like.

Not transfer-resistant

Our tester stated Kosas Eyebrow Pop has a velvety structure and a light-weight feeling. Many thanks to its triangular idea, this eyebrow pencil has both an accuracy factor and a thicker side. The multi-step system likewise includes an integrated spoolie for mixing and cleaning your hairs in the wanted instructions.

Though the vegan formula isn’t water-proof or transfer-resistant, the package features a clear laminating therapy that assists every little thing remain in location. Our tester stated it really felt sticky in the beginning, once completely dry, her eyebrows were cosy and soft. It likewise has castor oil to sustain eyebrow development, though there’s not a lots of research study on whether this really functions.

Tones: 10| Waterproof: No | Cruelty-Free: Yes

Byrdie/ Tamara Staples
Byrdie/ Tamara Staples
Byrdie/ Tamara Staples
Byrdie/ Tamara staples
Byrdie/ Tamara Staples

What Our Testers Claim

” I might likewise see myself making use of each item separately depending upon the day and what appearance I intend to attain.”— Jillian Raplee, Item Tester

Last Decision

Our finest total choice is Charlotte Tilbury’s Eyebrow Rip off Refillable Hair-Like Brow Pencil, a very pigmented formula that our tester stated glides on silky smooth in one stroke. For a much more cost effective choice, take into consideration e.l.f. cosmetics Immediate Raise Eyebrow Pencil. Our tester noted its velvety, pigmented structure makes application a cinch.

Just How We Evaluated

Our appeal editors took their time looking into the most effective eyebrow pencils on the marketplace and picked almost 40 to attempt in The Laboratory, our Manhattan product-testing center. Our testers checked different layout facets, consisting of the form, idea, dimension, developing needs, and noteworthy functions.

Next off, they tried the eyebrow pencils to see exactly how well they really executed. Each item was offered a rating from one to 5 based upon structure, really feel, pigment, color array, wear, and remaining power. Those with the highest possible ratings were inevitably picked for this summary.

Various Other Alternatives We Evaluated

L’Oréal Eyebrow Stylist Definer

We likewise attempted L’Oréal’s Eyebrow Stylist Definer, which has a wonderful uniformity, a retracting accuracy idea, and an integrated spoolie. Though we value the cost effective cost, the extreme pigment made it a little difficult to produce natural-looking strokes, and we want it can be found in a couple of even more dark tones.

Juvia’s Area I Shape, I Shield Eyebrow Pencil

This item has a somewhat completely dry uniformity, and the idea damaged a number of times throughout our screening. The pigment appeared well on our tester’s skin, yet the color array is rather restricting. Additionally, some shade moved onto her fingers when she ran them over her eyebrows.

Kylie Cosmetics Kybrow Pencil

We suched as the Kybrow Pencil’s smooth structure and valued that the strong idea really did not damage throughout our examinations. While we would certainly enjoy to see a couple of even more tones, the pigment was extremely natural-looking. The cost is spot-on, as well, so if it can be found in your color, we state purchase it.

Fulfill the Specialist

Bryan Cantor is a star make-up musician and appeal professional based in New york city City. He brings his excellent expertise of make-up items, skin care, application methods, and specialist suggestions and tricks to customers and business in New york city City and around the world.

What to Seek in an Eyebrow Pencil

The formula

Not all pencils are developed equivalent, notes Cantor. Traditional pencils are excellent for filling out eyebrows, while softer, twist-up, or retracting solutions usually produce much more hair-like strokes and are an excellent choice for those with thinner eyebrows, he states.

Integrated spoolie

Because mixing the pigment completely is critical for developing a natural-looking outcome, pencils with integrated spoolies are constantly a win and make the procedure less complicated, no added devices are called for.

FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTION.

Exactly how do you utilize a brow pencil?

Initially, attempt squashing the idea a little, pressing it perpendicularly versus a level surface area, Cantor states. After that, hold it at a 45-degree angle to your skin, and make use of fast, slim strokes that imitate hair.

Can you utilize a brow pencil as an eye liner?

In brief, yes, though not all brow pencils will certainly function too for this function. A soft, sharp pencil will certainly function, yet twist-ups normally will not, Cantor states. And no matter, bear in mind that any kind of eyebrow pencil is mosting likely to be much less pigmented than a standard eye liner which it should not be made use of in the waterline, he states.

What Is Byrdie Verified?

Did you discover the Byrdie Verified seal of authorization on top of this tale? This seal indicates that our group has actually looked into and evaluated every item on this listing making use of an one-of-a-kind technique that’s created to concentrate on what our visitors truly wish to know– and to supply understandings that you can not locate anywhere else. Sometimes, appeal brand names and public relations companies will certainly send us examples for insurance coverage factor to consider, yet our ideas and point of views are totally our very own. If you go to web links within our material, we might obtain payments from your acquisitions, yet we never ever obtain any kind of payment or factor to consider for the material of our referrals. Basically, the Byrdie Verified seal represents item referrals you can rely on.

Why Depend On Byrdie

Theresa Holland is a business appeal author, copyeditor, and item customer. Over the previous years, she’s attempted loads of brow items and recognizes exactly how to locate the most effective ones. Of the above brand names, she has actually directly made use of pencils from Charlotte Tilbury, Anastasia Beverly Hills, e.l.f., L’Oréal, and NYX. Theresa has actually been covering make-up, skin care, and hair care at Byrdie given that 2020. You can find out more of her service Traveling + Recreation and The Spruce.

According to our Variety Promise, 15% of items in our newly-published market summaries will certainly include Black-owned and/or Black-founded brand names. At the time of posting, we were unable to locate adequate brow pencils from Black-owned and/or Black-founded organizations to fulfill this percent. If you understand of one we must take into consideration, please email us at contact@byrdie.com and we will certainly examine the item ASAP.

Short article Resources.

Byrdie takes every chance to utilize top notch resources, consisting of peer-reviewed research studies, to sustain the truths within our write-ups. Review our content standards to read more regarding exactly how we maintain our material precise, trustworthy and reliable.

Maduri Virtual Reality, Vedachalam A, Kiruthika S. “Castor Oil” – The Offender of Intense Hair Felting. Int J Trichology 2017; 9( 3 ):116 -118. doi:10.4103/ ijt.ijt _ 22_17

Ideal Total.

Charlotte Tilbury Refillable Brow Pencil.

Runner-Up, Ideal Total.

Anastasia Beverly Hills Eyebrow Definer.

Ideal Budget plan.

e.l.f. Eyebrow Pencil.

Ideal Splurge.

Gucci Pastel Définition Sourcils Powder Brow Pencil.

Ideal Water resistant.

HUDA Appeal Eyebrow Pencil.

Best for Sporadic Eyebrows.

As Well Encountered Super Penalty Eyebrow Detailer Brow Pencil.

Ideal Pharmacy.

NYX Expert Make-up Brow Pomade.

Ideal Vegan.

Kosas Specifying Brow Pencil.

Last Decision

Just How We Evaluated

Various Other Alternatives We Evaluated

L’Oréal Eyebrow Stylist Definer

Juvia’s Area I Shape, I Shield Eyebrow Pencil

Kylie Cosmetics Kybrow Pencil

What to Seek in an Eyebrow Pencil

The formula

Integrated spoolie

What Is Byrdie Verified?

Why Depend On Byrdie

Related posts

Leave a Comment Cancel Reply